High intensity Vs low intensity training

High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) has taken off as a time-efficient, exciting new training method for quickly improving both endurance-performance and overall health. But is it really better than the good old fashioned long run?

HIIT training captured the nation’s interest after a BBC documentary (Trust me I’m a Doctor) claimed that just 3 lots of 20 second efforts performed three times a week could drastically improve one’s health.

But does this really mean that we, as runners, can completely do away with our age-old friend, the long steady run, and replace it with this new, spicier training method?  

Multiple research papers have proven HIIT training to be equally as effective as long steady runs at stimulating the physiological adaptations that lead to improved endurance performance.

Not convinced?

Researchers compared a HIIT training model, which used 4-6 repetitions of 30 second all out sprints, interspersed with 4 mins of recovery, with 90–120 minutes of steady running (65% of max effort).  Two groups of athletes completed 6 of these sessions over 14 days, the HIIT group totaling just 2.5 hours of training over the 2 weeks, whereas the traditional endurance group racked up 10.5 hours of training. The results showed athletes improved their time trial performance by 10.1% for HIIT and 7.5% for traditional endurance training.  

Is this enough proof for you to switch your training habits and bag yourself some more free time?

Research analysing the training habits on international and national level endurance runners showed that they spend up 80% of their training time completing long steady runs and dedicate 20% of training time to high intensity efforts. So, although still reliant on ‘getting the miles in the legs’ it seems even the pros are mixing up their training with these high intensity efforts.

Finally, a last attempt for the old guy, the ‘long slow runs’, at convincing you to stay as their faithful friend.

It is often said that the long slow runs are vital in improving ‘running economy’. This is a reduction in the energy required to sustain any given submaximal intensity. Indeed, it has been shown the running economy is improved through increasing the weekly volume (time spent) running.

However, further research has shown that the addition of HIIT training sessions to a traditional running plan accelerates the improvement in running economy.

So, the literature shows equal benefits of HIIT and long slow runs. But it is a case of replacing the old with the new?

No.. rather mixing the two to find your perfect recipe for success.

Science and numbers aside, I find long runs for me are vital for learning about pacing strategies, as well as nutritional strategies for my longer events.

I find them irreplaceably important in improving the durability of muscles and joints to withstand longer durations of impact. And aren’t they the real reason we all got into running in the first place, our enjoyment of running in the fresh air and taking in the sights with friends. If it keeps you motivated and happy, then stick at it!

However, if you don’t already have HIIT as part of your weekly regime I strongly advise adding at least one session a week.

I love my track sessions, and they are often the main focus of my training week. On top of the proven physiological benefits, I find these track sessions have a huge psychological benefit for me; teaching my mind to allow my body to be comfortable with being uncomfortable.

As one my favorite coaches said ‘if you always do what you have always done, you will always get what you have always got’.

Give the new guy, HIIT sessions, a go and play with the duration/layout of these sessions to stress your body in a way it is not used to, forcing those adaptations which will enhance your running performance.

Some of my favorite HIIT sessions are:

  • 5x 1km Reps with 2:00 min recovery (or a 2:1 work rest ratio depending on your pace)

  • 6x 800m reps with 1:40 recovery (just over a 2:1 work rest ratio on this one to allow you to really push hard on the efforts!)

  • 5x 400m reps with 1:1 work rest ratio.  A mid 3 minute rest then repeat 5x 400m again = 10x 400m reps in total. (This is a more advanced session)

  • Pyramid set of 30 seconds hard, 90 seconds easy, 60 seconds hard, 90 seconds easy, 90 seconds hard, 120 seconds easy and repeat back down.

I’d love to hear your experiences of using a combinations if HIIT and traditional endurance training, and how this has worked for you!

References:

Buchheit, Martin, and Paul B. Laursen. "High-intensity interval training, solutions to the programming puzzle." Sports medicine 43.10 (2013): 927-954.

Gibala, Martin J., et al. "Short‐term sprint interval versus traditional endurance training: similar initial adaptations in human skeletal muscle and exercise performance." The Journal of physiology 575.3 (2006): 901-911.

Previous
Previous

Meet Our Athletes